A Strength Training Brand Nearly Doubled Its Prime Big Deal Days Lift by Changing the Deal Type
A strength training accessories brand we work with ran last fall's Prime Big Deal Days without a Best Deal of any kind. Sales still came in at 2.6x a regular day, since the event itself drives real traffic to a listing whether or not that listing is discounted.
This year we changed the approach. Three of the brand's best selling lines went into Best Deals, and a newer product ran a 20% Prime Exclusive Discount instead. Same catalog, same event, a different deal type sitting on top of it.
US sales came in at 4.7x a regular day, nearly double the lift from the year before without a Best Deal in the mix. The difference showed up clearest when we split the catalog by deal type. Promo items lifted 5.0x over the two days, while full price items in the same catalog only lifted 1.5x.
That gap is the whole lesson. Prime Big Deal Days brings the traffic. It does not convert that traffic on its own. A shopper landing on a full price listing during the event behaves close to how they would on a regular Tuesday, and the 1.5x lift on full price items in this catalog backs that up. The deal is what turns a traffic spike into a sales spike.
The lift also was not even across the catalog, and that is worth paying attention to. The brand's women's line lifted 7.6x, and sales in Canada lifted 6.3x, up 154% from the year before. Putting the right SKUs into Best Deals mattered more than putting more SKUs into any deal at all.
The lines that made the strongest case for Best Deals were already the top sellers, the ones with the inventory and review base to support a traffic surge. The newer product got a smaller discount type because it had less of a track record to absorb that kind of volume safely. That split, proven sellers into the biggest deal type and newer items into a lighter one, is worth copying regardless of what you sell.
If you are planning deal type placement for the next event on the calendar, the question worth asking is not whether to run deals, it is which lines earn a Best Deal, which ones are better suited to a Prime Exclusive Discount, and which ones you are comfortable leaving at full price knowing they will ride the event's traffic without much lift. Defaulting every SKU to the same treatment is how a brand leaves a meaningful chunk of lift on the table.
We're glad to help you work through deal type placement before the next event hits, whether that's Black Friday, Cyber Monday, or next year's Prime Big Deal Days.





